Some Kids Just Aren’t Meant For College (Just As Long As We Are Talking About Your Kids, Not Mine)

By on February 8, 2019

From EQ:  “Some kids,” the Workforce Development Committee chair said, “just aren’t college material.”

A version of that statement has been uttered by countless participants in the countless number of workforce- and economic-development task forces and committees I’ve served on in my career. On the surface, a statement like that isn’t troubling — it’s the truth.

There are genuinely some people who don’t have an interest in or the ability to obtain a four-year degree.

The problem isn’t with the statement itself, or the reality that low-cost skills-based training alternatives need to be offered to students and adults who don’t have a four-year degree. The problem also isn’t a value-judgement on people who lack bachelor’s degrees. The smartest and most talented people I personally know are a former stay-at-home mom, a welder, a mechanic, and the manager of a Peterbilt dealership in rural Idaho.

Not a single one of those individuals has a college degree.

The problem is the hypocrisy and classism that drives much of the workforce and education discussion.

What do I mean?

Public sector workforce-development committees are usually stacked with the highly educated employees of local governments and other organizations with a stake in job creation and economic development. I once served on a workforce-development task force where the six participants had a combined eight graduate degrees. The irony of steering kids away from the educational opportunities that gave folks a seat at a table like that was lost on nearly every participant.

In my experience, private sector workforce-development task forces are usually stacked with successful owners and entrepreneurs. The hypocrisy in the industry-driven conversations isn’t best illustrated by the educational achievement of those owners and entrepreneurs. It’s best illustrated by how those entrepreneurs and owners choose to educate their own children.

Read more.


About Dede Hance